C-13-101 Medicare Appeals
👤 RESPONSIBLE POSITION | ROLE
Corporate Compliance Team
🎯 PURPOSE
All Medicare and Medicare Advantage clients have the right to appeal a discharge decision if the client/caregiver does not agree with the decision. When a branch location receives an appeal as outlined in O-7-131 Escalation of Appeal Requests, the Corporate Compliance Team will take the below steps to ensure Medicare Appeals are completed with all necessary information by the end of business day.
🔄 PROCESS
- Speak with the branch (either the Area Manager or Clinical Supervisor) to discuss the following:
- Learn more about the appeal. Inquire why they feel discharging is appropriate and why the client/caregiver disagrees. This information should be taken into consideration when pulling records later on.
- Confirm with the branch that they will not discharge until we have the appeal determination.
- Ensure the NOMNC is linked in and all visit notes have been synced back.
- Have the branch deliver the Detailed Notice of Non-Coverage. This can be done by phone (read them the notice) and then sent certified mail same day if they are unable to deliver it in person. The phone conversation should be documented in a cord note.
-
Pull the records for the appeal by the end of the current business day and save it in the appeal folder.

- The appeal notice is vague and used for all types of services so there is some need to deviate a bit from the list and use judgement on what will be needed depending on why we are discharging and why the client/caregiver disagrees.
- The records to pull are the following:
- NOMNC, Detailed Notice of Non-Coverage, and the coordination note of the phone conversation on the Detailed Notice of Non Coverage (if it occurred over the phone).
- Referring information including the orders to admit to HC and f2f documentation we used.
- The patient information report (do not include the coordination notes).
- SOC OASIS and/or recert OASIS if we saw the client over multiple episodes, including any other eval visits that occurred.
- Current POC. If the client has been on services for multiple episodes, I will also pull those to show the timeline of services we have provided.
- Any add on discipline orders in the current cert period.
- If therapy is involved, all assessment visits within the cert period.
- The last few home care visits (the appeal letter states last 3 days’ worth but we should send last 3 visits of the skilled disciplines, at minimum).
- Combine the records in the order listed in step 2.
- Once the records have been pulled and combined, upload them to the E-Lift portal (see fax for the case control ID and Electronic Key information).
- Monitor the status for the branch (most determinations occur within 24 hours) and e-mail the branch with an update on the status daily. The branch will receive a detailed determination letter by fax. This will need to be attached to HCHB.
- If Commerce Health agrees with the discharge, we can move forward and schedule the DC visit.
NOTE
If Commerce Health does not agree with the discharge, we will need to get new orders to extend the POC.
📅 Effective: 10.21.2026 | 🛠️ Revised: N/A | ✅ Approved: JS
